Fold-worthy pies, wild specialty toppings, and a vibe that makes Gallatin Pike worth the drive.
Some pizza places play it safe. Pinky Ring Pizza does not. Since opening on Gallatin Pike South in Madison, TN, this spot has built a loyal following of 950-plus reviews and a 4.5-star reputation on the back of one simple obsession: pizza that actually tastes like New York.
The crust is thin, the char is real, and the slices are big enough to fold. The menu goes far beyond a basic pepperoni, though. The Fat Tony loads up with enough personality to justify its name, and the Mike's Hot brings heat that lingers in the best way. There is even a pickle pizza on the board, and yes, it is delicious. Ricotta appears where it should, in generous, creamy dollops that turn a great pie into a memorable one.
The room feels like a proper date-night spot, which is a rarity on this stretch of Madison. Bring someone you want to impress, order the 18-inch, and plan on leftovers.
Pinky Ring Pizza serves New York-style pies in sizes built for sharing, starting at 18 inches for groups of two or three. Every pie is made on a hand-stretched thin crust and finished in a hot oven that delivers the crisp bottom and chewy edge that define the style.
Signature builds like the Fat Tony and Mike's Hot are the headliners, but the kitchen welcomes custom orders with a full lineup of toppings that includes the now-legendary pickle pizza. Ricotta is available and highly recommended. The menu also works for office lunch runs, with large-format orders that travel well and arrive ready to impress a full staff.
Dine in for the full atmosphere or call ahead for pickup. Whether you are a Madison regular finally making your first visit or someone who has been coming back since day one, the kitchen is turning out the same quality pie every time.
Take a look at our space and what we have to offer
“Best pizza in the Nashville area. Amazing pizza and great staff! The hot pickle is out of this world and the pepperoni is the best I’ve had.”
— Abe and Shawna
Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers
Pinky Ring Pizza serves New York-style pizza: hand-stretched thin crust, large foldable slices, and a crispy-chewy texture that is authentic to the style.
The Fat Tony and Mike's Hot are two of the most popular specialty pies. The pickle pizza has developed a serious following, and adding ricotta to any pie is strongly recommended by regulars.
Pinky Ring Pizza offers 18-inch pies that comfortably feed three people with a few slices left over, making them great for groups or office orders.
Yes. Reviewers specifically call it out as a great date-night spot. The atmosphere is relaxed but has real personality, and the food is impressive enough to make a good impression.
Absolutely. Multiple large-format pies travel well and the variety of specialty toppings gives everyone something to try. Call ahead for larger orders.
The restaurant is at 414 Gallatin Pike S in Madison, TN 37115. More details and the current menu are available at pinkyringpizza.com.
Pinky Ring Pizza operates as a walk-in friendly spot. For large groups or big pickup orders, calling ahead is always a good idea to make sure your order is ready when you arrive.
Local places a short distance away, each with its own Doozer site. Tap any card to visit.
0.6 mi308 Williams Ave, Madison, TN 37115, USA
1.6 mi1508A Gallatin Pike S, Madison, TN 37115, USA
2.5 mi3449 Dickerson Pike, Nashville, TN 37207, USA
3.8 mi600 Opry Mills Dr, Nashville, TN 37214, USA
3.8 mi1309 McGavock Pk, Nashville, TN 37216, USA
Other spots near here, whatever their type. Tap one to open its page.